When it comes to making the decision about which type of living situation is best for you or a loved one, it can be difficult to know what to choose. There are many factors to consider, such as budget, care needs, and lifestyle preferences. In this article, we will discuss the differences between independent living and assisted living, helping you to decide which option is best for your loved one.
Contents
Assisted Living Community
Assisted living is a type of senior living community that provides assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs). This can include things like bathing, dressing, grooming, and medication management. Assisted living communities also offer social activities and opportunities for residents to interact with one another.
Independent Living Community
Independent living, on the other hand, is for seniors who want to live on their own but may need a bit of help with things like cooking or cleaning. Independent living communities typically have staff on-site 24/7 to provide assistance as needed, but residents maintain a high degree of independence and freedom.
Compare Independent Living and Assisted Living Communities
| Assisted Living Community | Independent Living Community | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost & Payment | The cost of assisted living can vary depending on the size and location of the community, but it typically falls within the range of $900 to $4,000 per month. Most assisted living facilities offer a variety of payment options, including monthly rent, flat fees, and pay-as-you-go plans. | Independent living communities do not typically require a deposit or long-term contract, so they are a more affordable option for seniors who want to maintain their independence. The cost for independent living varies depending on the location and amenities offered by each community, but it generally falls between $600 and $2,000 per month. |
| Medical and Supportive Care | In assisted living, you can expect to have access to on-site nurses, as well as support staff who can help with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as bathing, dressing, and grooming. In terms of medical care, you can expect to receive assistance with managing chronic conditions, as well as help getting to appointments and receiving treatments. | Independent living communities do not offer on-site nurses or support staff. However, most independent living facilities have relationships with local home health agencies that provide these services for a fee. As for medical care, you will usually be responsible for managing your own chronic conditions and getting to appointments on your own. However, many independent living facilities have wellness programs that include educational seminars and opportunities for socializing with others who also have chronic conditions. |
| Community Design & Living Spaces | Community living in assisted living facilities can be quite different from independent living. Most assisted living communities are designed like small villages, with a central building that houses the dining hall, common areas, and medical facilities. There are usually several apartment buildings scattered around this "village", each with its own set of common areas. | For independent living facilities, the design can vary widely. Some independent living communities are designed like small villages, too, with a central building that houses the dining hall, common areas, and medical facilities. However, many independent living communities are simply a collection of apartment buildings or homes clustered together. |
| Family Involvement | In assisted living, the level of family involvement required is much higher. In most cases, the elderly person's children or other close relatives are responsible for managing their care. This includes making sure they take their medications on time, go to their doctor appointments, and eat properly. It can be a lot of work to manage a loved one's care, but it also gives families a sense of purpose and can create strong bonds. | Independent living communities, on the other hand, are designed for seniors who want to maintain their independence. Families are welcome to visit, but they are not responsible for the resident's care. This can be a great option for older adults who still have some mobility and don't need help with basic activities of daily living. |
| Amenities, Programming and Services | The amenities and services that are unique to assisted living communities vary depending on the provider, but often include things like assistance with basic activities of daily living (bathing, dressing, grooming, etc.), medication management, dining services, transportation assistance, and recreational and social activities. | For independent living, the amenities and services that are unique to this kind of community can include independent living apartments or homes, grocery stores and other retail businesses on-site or in close proximity, restaurants and cafes on-site or in close proximity, a variety of social activities available within the community and beyond, and access to healthcare services as needed |
| Access to Staff | In assisted living, residents' access to staff is typically more comprehensive. In addition to having access to healthcare professionals, assisted living residents typically have 24-hour access to supportive staff who can provide assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs), such as bathing, dressing, and grooming. | Residents in independent living communities may also have access to supportive staff, but this is not always the case. Depending on the community and each resident, you may only have access to staff during certain hours or you may not have any direct contact with staff at all. |
| Meals and Snacks | Assisted living provides residents with three meals and two snacks per day. These meals are typically served in the community dining room, but some facilities have the option of bringing food to residents rooms. | Independent living communities vary when it comes to providing meals and snacks. Some communities offer all residents three meals a day, while others only provide snacks. Its important to ask about meal and snack options when touring independent living communities. |
| Medication Management | In assisted living, medication management is typically provided for all residents. This means that a staff member will help residents remember to take their medications and will keep track of any changes in medication dosage or type. | In independent living, medication management is typically not provided for all residents. This means that its up to the resident or their loved ones to keep track of medications and changes in dosage or type. |
| Housekeeping Services | Housekeeping in assisted living is typically provided for all residents. This means that a staff member will help residents keep their living space clean and organized. | Housekeeping in independent living is not typically provided for all residents. This means that its up to the resident or their loved ones to keep their living space clean and organized. |
| Transportation | In assisted living, transportation is typically provided for all residents. This means that a staff member will help residents get to and from their appointments, errands, and social activities. | In independent living, transportation is not typically provided for all residents. This means that its up to the resident or their loved ones to get themselves to where they need to be. This helps foster more independence in residents. |
| Assistance with ADLs | Assisted living is known to assist with ADLs because its one of the main focuses of this type of living situation. This means that residents will have help with things like bathing, dressing, and grooming. This helps to ensure that all residents are comfortable and taken care of. | On the other hand, independent living typically does not offer this type of assistance. This doesnt mean that residents cant get help with ADLs if they need it, but it typically isnt offered as a part of the package. |
The differences between assisted living and independent living:
1. Cost & Payment
Cost and payment for assisted living
The cost of assisted living can vary depending on the size and location of the community, but it typically falls within the range of $900 to $4,000 per month. Most assisted living facilities offer a variety of payment options, including monthly rent, flat fees, and pay-as-you-go plans.
Cost & payment for independent living
Independent living communities do not typically require a deposit or long-term contract, so they are a more affordable option for seniors who want to maintain their independence. The cost for independent living varies depending on the location and amenities offered by each community, but it generally falls between $600 and $2,000 per month.
Do assisted living or independent living communities accept Medicare or Medicaid?
Medicare and Medicaid are government-funded healthcare programs that offer coverage for a variety of services, including long-term care. However, the rules for which assisted living communities accept these programs vary from state to state.
2. Medical and Supportive Care
Medical & supportive care in assisted living
In assisted living, you can expect to have access to on-site nurses, as well as support staff who can help with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as bathing, dressing, and grooming. In terms of medical care, you can expect to receive assistance with managing chronic conditions, as well as help getting to appointments and receiving treatments.
Medical & supportive care in independent living
Independent living communities do not offer on-site nurses or support staff. However, most independent living facilities have relationships with local home health agencies that provide these services for a fee.
As for medical care, you will usually be responsible for managing your own chronic conditions and getting to appointments on your own. However, many independent living facilities have wellness programs that include educational seminars and opportunities for socializing with others who also have chronic conditions.
3. Community Design & Living Spaces
Community living in assisted living
Community living in assisted living facilities can be quite different from independent living. Most assisted living communities are designed like small villages, with a central building that houses the dining hall, common areas, and medical facilities. There are usually several apartment buildings scattered around this “village”, each with its own set of common areas.
Community living in independent living
For independent living facilities, the design can vary widely. Some independent living communities are designed like small villages, too, with a central building that houses the dining hall, common areas, and medical facilities. However, many independent living communities are simply a collection of apartment buildings or homes clustered together.
4. Family Involvement
Family involvement in assisted living
In assisted living, the level of family involvement required is much higher. In most cases, the elderly person’s children or other close relatives are responsible for managing their care. This includes making sure they take their medications on time, go to their doctor appointments, and eat properly. It can be a lot of work to manage a loved one’s care, but it also gives families a sense of purpose and can create strong bonds.
Family Involvement in independent living
Independent living communities, on the other hand, are designed for seniors who want to maintain their independence. Families are welcome to visit, but they are not responsible for the resident’s care. This can be a great option for older adults who still have some mobility and don’t need help with basic activities of daily living.
5. Amenities, Programming and Services
Amenities & services in assisted living
The amenities and services that are unique to assisted living communities vary depending on the provider, but often include things like:
- Assistance with basic activities of daily living (bathing, dressing, grooming, etc.)
- Medication management
- Dining services
- Transportation assistance
- Recreational and social activities
Amenities & services in independent living
For independent living, the amenities and services that are unique to this kind of community can include:
- Independent living apartments or homes
- Grocery stores and other retail businesses on-site or in close proximity
- Restaurants and cafes on-site or in close proximity
- A variety of social activities available within the community and beyond
- Access to healthcare services as needed
6. Access to Staff
Access to staff in assisted living
In assisted living, residents’ access to staff is typically more comprehensive. In addition to having access to healthcare professionals, assisted living residents typically have 24-hour access to supportive staff who can provide assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs), such as bathing, dressing, and grooming.
Access to staff in independent living
Residents in independent living communities may also have access to supportive staff, but this is not always the case. Depending on the community and each resident, you may only have access to staff during certain hours or you may not have any direct contact with staff at all.
7. Meals and Snacks
Meals & snacks in assisted living
Assisted living provides residents with three meals and two snacks per day. These meals are typically served in the community dining room, but some facilities have the option of bringing food to residents’ rooms.
Meals & snacks independent living
Independent living communities vary when it comes to providing meals and snacks. Some communities offer all residents three meals a day, while others only provide snacks. It’s important to ask about meal and snack options when touring independent living communities.
8. Medication Management
Medication management in assisted living
In assisted living, medication management is typically provided for all residents. This means that a staff member will help residents remember to take their medications and will keep track of any changes in medication dosage or type.
Medication management in independent living
In independent living, medication management is typically not provided for all residents. This means that it’s up to the resident or their loved ones to keep track of medications and changes in dosage or type.
9. Housekeeping Services
Housekeeping in assisted living
Housekeeping in assisted living is typically provided for all residents. This means that a staff member will help residents keep their living space clean and organized.
Housekeeping in independent living
Housekeeping in independent living is not typically provided for all residents. This means that it’s up to the resident or their loved ones to keep their living space clean and organized.
10. Transportation
Transportation in assisted living
In assisted living, transportation is typically provided for all residents. This means that a staff member will help residents get to and from their appointments, errands, and social activities.
Transportation in independent living
In independent living, transportation is not typically provided for all residents. This means that it’s up to the resident or their loved ones to get themselves to where they need to be. This helps foster more independence in residents.
11. Assistance with ADLs
Assistance with ADLs in assisted living
Assisted living is known to assist with ADLs because it’s one of the main focuses of this type of living situation. This means that residents will have help with things like bathing, dressing, and grooming. This helps to ensure that all residents are comfortable and taken care of.
Assistance with ADLs in independent living
On the other hand, independent living typically does not offer this type of assistance. This doesn’t mean that residents can’t get help with ADLs if they need it, but it typically isn’t offered as a part of the package.
Choosing between independent living and assisted living
To choose between independent living and assisted living, you need to ask yourself a few questions:
- How much help do I need with my ADLs?
- Do I want or need more social interaction?
- Can I afford the monthly cost of assisted living?
- What type of environment do I want to live in?
These are just a few of the questions you should ask yourself when trying to decide between independent living and assisted living. The best way to find the answer is to visit some communities under each type of facility and talk to the residents there. They will be able to give you a first-hand account of what it’s like to live in that community.
You can also ask these questions to help you decide for your loved one if you need to. The goal is to find the right fit for you or them, whether that means independent living or assisted living.
Final Thoughts
The differences between independent living and assisted living can be summed up in two words: choice and flexibility. With assisted living, you give up some of your choices to receive more support. This might include choosing a pre-made meal instead of cooking yourself, or accepting help with medication management. With independent living, you maintain control over all aspects of your life while still having access to assistance as needed.
In terms of flexibility, assisted living usually offers more set schedules and routines, while independent living allows for a greater degree of freedom and spontaneity. If you’re trying to decide which is the right choice for you or your loved one, it’s important to weigh all the pros and cons carefully. The most important thing is to guarantee comfort and happiness.
For more information on skilled nursing facilities or assisted living and independent living communities, contact Eden Senior Care today. We can help you get answers to general questions about assisted living and independent living. We would be happy to assist you in any way that we can.
Also see: Skilled Nursing vs. Assisted Living, Assisted Living vs. In-Home Care